We check this website, now firstmutuallife.com is up and dont blocked for our system and other users of the Internet.
So, answer to question: Is firstmutuallife Down Right Now? - NO! firstmutuallife is up!
If you have problem with access to site firstmutuallife, and domain firstmutuallife.com is not avalible.
Clear browser cache and/or try other web browser
(Chrome, Firefox or Safari).